In the expansion draft that was held seven years ago, the Calgary Flames figured they might lose Giguere and get nothing in return so they swapped him for a second-round draft pick. In retrospect, it was a spectacularly cheap acquisition for the Ducks.
Now, at age 30, Giguere is as technically strong a butterfly specialist as there is in the league, and his presence in the Anaheim crease is being viewed as an edge for the Ducks going into Game 1 of the championship series Monday night.
The 2003 playoff MVP from Montreal has a ton more big-game experience than does the Ottawa Senators' Ray Emery. The 24-year-old native of Cayuga, Ont., is fantastically athletic with sharp reflexes but sometimes leaves too many rebounds and who, remember, is in just his first season as a No. 1 big-league puck stopper.
Giguere has the superior stats during the playoffs this spring - 1.87 to Emery's 1.95 in goals-against average, and a .931 save percentage compared to Emery's .919.
The two have dissimilar goaltending styles and personalities. The fact Giguere wears 35 and Emery wears 1 is a coincidental but apt reflection of the differences.
Giguere is not flashy. More often than not, he's quiet around his teammates. He's a straight-as-an-arrow family man, which was magnified on the eve of the playoffs when he briefly left the team to tend to his infant son Maxime, who was born April 4 with no sight in his right eye. Giguere himself has a rare physical condition where his body takes in too much air when drinking, which causes an advanced rate of dehydration. He takes his helmet off frequently to minimize sweating during stoppages in play.
Giguere hasn't always received the recognition he deserves.
"That's probably because he plays on the West Coast," says teammate Andy McDonald. "Everyone in our locker-room really appreciates what he does and is aware of his ability.
"He's one of the elite goaltenders in this league and I just think that, in terms of (media) coverage, somebody on the West Coast isn't going to get as much attention."
Emery was drafted and developed by the Senators. He's single. He is a charismatic figure who says that if he were not a pro athlete he'd be designing clothes or operating a clothing store. It is said that he ate a cockroach last season on a dare by teammate Daniel Alfredsson. He's been in scraps during games, getting two major fighting penalties during a punch-up with the Buffalo Sabres in a game last February. He had the audacity to have an image of notorious boxer Mike Tyson on his mask, although he's changed to Canadian fight legend George Chuvalo now.
Anaheim coach Randy Carlyle certainly admires the way Emery has risen to the playoff occasion.
"He seems to be taking another step of maturing into a high-level goaltender," said Carlyle. "I don't think that they really thought that Emery would be their goaltender at this point in the season, but he's earned it.
"It's a tribute to the player and their organization for the development of that player."
Giguere, who played his last junior hockey seasons with the QMJHL's Halifax Mooseheads, has for his entire tenure with the Ducks worked closely with Francois Allaire, the Boisbriand, Que., goaltending guru who helped Patrick Roy become a star.
Emery, who played in the OHL for the Sault Ste. Marie Greyhounds, has been honing the technical aspects of his play with Ron Low, the former NHL goalie and coach from Birtle, Man., who joined the Senators' staff just before last season.
With the Stanley Cup on the line, it's Jiggy versus Sugar Ray in the creases.