Was women’s gold medal match botched by ref? Kerry Fraser says ‘no’, but feels game needs two-ref system

Jason Kay
Ice Hockey - Winter Olympics Day 13 - Canada v United States

For Team USA in Sochi yesterday, there was no joy and too much Joy all at once.

The work of British referee Joy Tottman came under intense scrutiny after she called three penalties in overtime and Canada won the thriller on the power play.

Hilary Knight claimed the penalty call against her, the one that led to the golden goal, was “bogus.” She says she didn’t touch Hayley Wickenheiser, who had fallen to the ice on a breakaway.

It followed a slashing infraction whistled against Jocelyne Lamoureux, who tapped Shannon Szabados’ pads while Team USA was on a power play of its own.

The chain of events sparked controversy all over the world wide web and, for some, evoked memories of the gold medal women’s game in Salt Lake 12 years ago when referee Stacey Livingston called eight consecutive penalties against the Canadians.

We decided to turn to an expert for his take on what transpired in one of the most entertaining games you’ll ever witness. Here’s what former NHL ref Kerry Fraser had to say on:

Read more

THN in Sochi: Controversy in women’s hockey turns to refereeing

Ken Campbell
Joy Tottman

SOCHI – This much we know about Joy Tottman: She is the governance and compliance officer for the Sport and Recreation Alliance in Britain. She has refereed at the women’s level internationally for 15 years, including at the 2006 and 2010 Winter Olympics and she does a fair bit of refereeing of men’s professional hockey in the English Premier League.

And depending upon what side you’re on, she either made a mockery of the women’s gold medal game at the Olympics or had the guts to make bold calls in overtime.

Much of the talk surrounding women’s hockey at the Olympics, before this game, centered around whether or not the sport is competitive enough world-wide to even belong in the Olympics at all. International Ice Hockey Federation president Rene Fasel poured cold water on that notion when he declared it is not going anywhere. And don’t forget, Fasel is the winter sports representative on the executive board of the International Olympic Committee, so he holds a fair bit of sway.

Now the talk will be whether or not the refereeing needs to get better at this level. What will come under scrutiny will be two penalty calls Tottman made in overtime which led to a 5-on-3 power play, on which Canada scored in overtime. With Canada killing a penalty and creating a 4-on-3 during overtime, Tottman whistled Jocelyn Lamoureux for a controversial slashing penalty.

Then with Hayley Wickenheiser on a breakaway and Hilary Knight trying to catch her, Wickenheiser went down and Knight was called for crosschecking, of all things. When she made the call, Tottman pointed to center ice, which led everyone, including Canadian coach Kevin Dineen, to believe Wickenheiser would be awarded a penalty shot. Knight later said Tottman made “a bogus call,” and that she didn’t make contact with Wickenheiser and USA coach Katey Stone offered a stern, “No comment,” when asked what she thought of the call.

It’s difficult to fathom Wickenheiser would fall without there being at least some contact being made and it’s absolutely ridiculous to suggest she took a dive. She was on a breakaway in overtime of the gold medal game and had the puck on her stick with the opportunity to end the game. Players don’t dive in those circumstances.

But the questions will continue to linger, on both the Lamoureux and Knight penalties. It’s hard to argue that Tottman was out of her element, given her history refereeing women’s hockey. And she was assigned the gold medal game, not because she’s from a neutral country, but because she earned it with her work in previous games in the tournament. But it does beg the question of whether the officiating at the highest level must improve.

“The game is growing in leaps and bounds,” Stone said. “The speed and pace of the game is tremendous and it’s a great, great product. We have to make sure that every part of the game operations and game management is developing at as a fast a rate as it possibly can.”

“Look at it from their shoes,” Dineen said. “I don’t know how much in-game preparation they get. You look on the men’s side…and they’re seeing 80, 100 games a year and they see a lot of scenarios play out. They get exposed to that, but on the women’s side, they don’t see all the things that play out. At the end of it, I think the game was decided on the ice.”

THN in Sochi: From Wickenheiser to Poulin, the torch is passed

Ken Campbell
Marie-Philip Poulin

SOCHI – Over the next little while, Marie-Philip Poulin might want to brush up on her Canadian hockey history, you know, acquaint herself a little better with the likes of Paul Henderson in 1972, Mario Lemieux and Wayne Gretzky in 1987, John Slaney in 1991 and Sidney Crosby in 2010. Because on this wild, magical night in Russia, Marie-Philip Poulin of Beauceville, Que., took her rightful place beside them.

To recap: With four minutes left in the women’s gold medal game in the Sochi Olympics, Canada looks deader than road kill. It looks as though Team USA is finally, 16 years and three days after their gold medal in Nagano, going to take its rightful place at the top of the podium. Then a fluke goal off somebody’s knee, then the tying goal from Poulin, then a host of controversial penalties in overtime and Poulin having the puck on her stick with an open net. Read more

THN in Sochi: Swiss women craft own Miracle on Ice

Ken Campbell
Lutz scores

SOCHI – In the history of women’s hockey at the international level, including the medals in these Olympics, there will have been a total of 78 medals awarded in the Olympics, World Championships and Under-18 World Championships. Canada, USA, Finland and Sweden have won all but five of them.

So it’s not often that a team such as Switzerland manages to crash the party. But if these Olympics have taught us anything, at least when it comes to the hockey tournaments, it’s to never, ever be surprised. Despite falling behind 2-0 after two periods, the Swiss women scored four straight goals in the third period to defeat Sweden 4-3 and win the bronze medal. It represents the first time ever that a team other than Canada, USA, Finland or Sweden has won a medal. Read more

IIHF president Fasel’s defense of women’s Olympic hockey a welcome sight

Adam Proteau
Natalie Spooner

Questions about the future of women’s hockey at the Olympics were answered directly by International Ice Hockey Federation president Rene Fasel Tuesday at the Sochi Games. And to the delight of fans of the women’s game, he delivered some heartening news by stating definitively that women’s hockey would never be removed as an Olympics sport.

“That will never happen,” Fasel said at a news conference in regard to dropping women’s hockey. “I can guarantee that.”

In 2010, then-International Olympic Committee president Jacques Rogge caused consternation by suggesting women’s hockey had to improve its competitive parity or face the possibility of being removed from the Games. But Fasel’s strong statement should put any worries to rest. While it’s true he isn’t the one ultimately making the decisions – that’s the I.O.C.’s job – the 64-year-old has been an I.O.C. member since 1995 and sits on its executive board as their winter sports delegate. If there was a serious move afoot to take the women’s game away, I suspect he wouldn’t be so confident in his choice of words Tuesday. But he was. Read more

THN in Sochi: USA, Canada ready for epic battle

Ken Campbell

SOCHI – Looking forward to the women’s gold medal game at the 2014 Sochi Olympics, Canadian veteran Hayley Wickenheiser channeled her inner Coleman Young. “What is it they say, ‘Courage is one step ahead of fear?’ “ Wickenheiser said, quoting the former mayor of Detroit.

Fear is one thing Wickenheiser almost certainly won’t have going into the gold medal game against USA Thursday night. This will be her fifth championship game at the Olympics. She has been on the winning end of things three times. And at the age of 35, she is leading a team that is loaded with veteran talent.

If there is one area where Canada has big edge over the Americans, it’s in veteran experience. Both Wickenheiser and Jayna Hefford will be going for their fourth Olympic gold medals, while no player on the American team even has one. Captain Julie Chu has two silvers and a bronze.

“We’re going for a different color this time,” Chu said. American coach Katey Stone agreed. “It’s about time (Chu won a gold medal), isn’t it?”

Chu and her teammates may very well finally reach their goal. They’re young, fast and determined and have plenty of offensive firepower, something they showed in their 6-1 win over Sweden in the tournament semifinal. Canada, by contrast, had chance after outstanding chance in its 3-1 win over Switzerland in the other semifinal, but struggled to put pucks past goalie Florence Schelling.

But anyone who has played at a high level before knows the value of experience. Wickenheiser, for example, has seen everything. She has been on the winning end against the Americans far more than the losing end and there will be little that can rattle her.

“I think you always rely on what your make-up is and for us that’s a strong veteran presence,” Dineen said. “We have people who have been there before. We’ve also got a pretty good blend. There’s some real skill and high-end talent, including that group of veteran talent. I think the scale is pretty evenly matched, but any time we have meetings, people who have walked in these shoes before can certainly help us.”

Dineen is right about the scales being matched between these two teams. Including Canada’s 3-2 win over USA in the preliminary round, Dineen’s first as Canadian coach after taking over for Dan Church, the two teams have played eight times this season with each team winning four games. The Americans have outscored the Canadians 25-22, but Canada has won the games that have counted most so far – one in the Four Nations Tournament and the other in the preliminary round of the Olympics. And, of course their history of getting into fights has been well-documented.

“It’s going to be intense, they’re going to be at their best and we’re going to have to be our best,” said American defender Gigi Marvin. “We’re ready and we’re excited.”

“It comes down to one game and anything can happen,” said Canadian forward Meghan Agosta. “I think the better team is going to come out on top…and there’s no doubt in my mind that it’s going to be us.”

NOTES: A couple of great quotes came out of the Canada-Switzerland game. Swiss coach Rene Kammerer: “I’m very proud to be disappointed about our losing.” And Canadian coach Kevin Dineen, when asked why he was coaching women’s hockey: “Well, for one, I got fired and it opened up some real possibilities.”


THN in Sochi: Women’s hockey still has a long way to go

Ken Campbell
Chu and Vetter

Four years ago, then International Olympic Committee president Jacques Rogge put women’s hockey on what was known in the movie Animal House as “double secret probation.” In reality, Rogge put a warning shot right across the bow of the sport.

“There is a discrepancy, everyone agrees with that,” Rogge said. “We cannot continue without improvement.”

Four years later, there is a new man running the IOC in Thomas Bach, but the reality is that almost nothing has changed in women’s hockey. Bach has apparently already told the powers that be with the national federations that he wants women’s hockey to stay in the Olympics for gender equality. Nothing wrong with that. But if that’s the case, those with a vested interest in the sport owe Bach big-time. Read more

THN in Sochi: Canada vs. USA for gold…again

Ken Campbell
Canadian women

SOCHI – For the fourth time in five Olympics, Canada and USA will meet for a gold medal in women’s hockey, meaning Canadian veterans Hayley Wickenheiser and Jayna Hefford are one win away from the unique distinction of winning gold medals in four separate Olympics.

But they’ll have to overcome a formidable foe in order to do it. The Americans looked utterly dominant in their 6-1 win over Sweden, while Canada had a plethora of opportunities, but struggled a little to find the back of the net in its 3-1 win over Switzerland in the other semifinal. If not for the fine play of Swiss goalie Florence Schelling, plus two goals called back for Canada, this game would have been a blowout.

Natalie Spooner scored two goals for Canada in the victory and Melodie Daoust also scored for Canada. Jessica Lutz replied for Switzerland, touching off a huge celebration on their bench during which the players were literally dancing to the arena music.

The gold medal game is set for Sunday. I’ll have an updated blog and more analysis later.

THN’s Three Stars: Natalie Spooner (Canada); 2. Florence Schelling (Switzerland); 3. Hayley Wickenheiser (Canada).