• SHARE:
  • email
  • Bookmark and Share

THN.com Blog: Should youngsters be fighting?

Darcy Hordichuk of the Vancouver Canucks and Jared Boll of the
Columbus Blue Jackets exchange punches. (Photo by Jeff Vinnick/NHLI via Getty Images)

Zoom Image

Darcy Hordichuk of the Vancouver Canucks and Jared Boll of the Columbus Blue Jackets exchange punches. (Photo by Jeff Vinnick/NHLI via Getty Images)

I hate to harp on fighting in hockey. I know it has been addressed by many throughout the hockey world, including myself. And I know many of you are sick of the debate. But two recent incidents have me leaning further to the anti-fighting side of the argument.

The first happened last Tuesday when Chicago first-rounder Kyle Beach’s delayed empty-net breakaway touched-off a Western League brawl. The second was a staged American League fight over the weekend that left one combatant suffering a seizure.

Both are just the latest examples of the ugly side of hockey. The side that turns fans into Roman plebs on one hand and shocks them into horrified silence on the other.

It’s not that I don’t enjoy a good hockey fight or that I think there’s absolutely no place for it in the NHL. But at some point, maybe you should throw out the baby with the bath water, when it’s the baby that’s the problem.

So how about a compromise? Legislate fighting out of junior and the American League.

The world’s best players know when and how to fight. And they normally do so under controlled circumstances; as adults governed by a historical code of ethics. But I wouldn’t want my son getting punched-out - or worse - because another kid thought he deserved it. And I don’t enjoy seeing kids turn violent. But it’s happening. Because of a top-down hockey culture that encourages fighting.

And since when do adults trust teenagers and testosterone-filled young men to decide anything of life-and-death importance? Hockey isn’t war. Many of these players can’t legally drink or vote, but they’re allowed to decide right and wrong during the heat of battle? C’mon.

Legislating fighting out of the game at the lower levels would mean fewer players make the NHL based on their fisticuff abilities. And the ones who do will be more like Jarome Iginla than Derek Boogaard. I’ll take the former over the latter anytime.

Fans who champion fighting as a necessary release for players who play a physical game, carry metal sticks and skate up to 30 miles-per-hour would still get their fix with NHL fights. Those who say fighting is merely a hangover from a baser time in hockey’s history would have something to build upon. And the NHL would still be able to market fighting.

Related Links

So flip the script hockey fans. Legislate fighting out of hockey at lower levels and see what a trickle-up effect can affect.  

And now for some happier thoughts from my first all-star weekend experience…

If Tim Thomas’ performance didn’t prove he’s the best goalie in the world right now, I don’t know what else can. Whether it was the skills competition or the big game, he was awesome…

Speaking of goalies, Jason Maggio has to feel good about his all-star performance as well. The 21-year-old from the junior double-A Dollard Vipers (Montreal) stopped 29 of 34 shots during the Fan Fav Breakaway Challenge on Saturday…

Despite the opinion of the THNer who shall remain nameless, the Brangelina Award for beautiful people at the THN/NHL All-Star party Friday night goes to Mrs. and Mr. Willa Ford of the Dallas Stars

Zdeno Chara has a big shot. Really big. But he’s also big. Really, really big. At 5-foot-8, when I get out of bed in the morning, I’m used to looking up at people. But when the-still-in-full-equipment-Chara parted the forest of people in the East dressing room after the skills I was awestruck. I literally stepped out of his way for fear he wouldn’t see me…

Alex Ovechkin’s performance brought smiles to the faces of those of us watching from the press box, the most jaded of hockey fans. And he’s a crowd-pleaser off the ice, too. The NHL needs many more like him. I know they’re out there.

John Grigg is a copy editor with The Hockey News and a regular contributor to THN.com with his blog and the Top 10.

For more great profiles, news and views from the world of hockey, Subscribe to The Hockey News magazine.

More Stories

THN.com Blog: Contract opt-out option fair for NHL, NHLPA

They say money makes the world go ‘round. But it can also make it come crashing down....

THN.com Blog: Free-falling Avalanche building in right direction

Remember when the Colorado Avalanche were good? It wasn’t that long ago. Seriously....

THN.com Blog: Ovechkin, Capitals crushing NHL with new responsible, winning system

You know when you have one of those “whew’” moments? Like, “thank God I...

THN.com Blog: The low-lights of 99 entries

Ah, the perils of public prognostication. Putting yourself out there for all the world to read...
blog comments powered by Disqus

THN on Twitter

Who will win the 2013-14 Selke Trophy?





Contests

Our Partners