• Print

THN.com Blog: Burke's managerial mettle put to the test

Brian Burke helped bulid the Ducks into a Stanley Cup champion, but has run into cap troubles this off-season. (Photo by Bruce Bennett/Getty Images)

Zoom Image

Brian Burke helped bulid the Ducks into a Stanley Cup champion, but has run into cap troubles this off-season. (Photo by Bruce Bennett/Getty Images)

There is no disputing the fact: camp is a four-letter word.

It’s the place your parents banished you to – one with no amenities and swarms of bugs – so they could have “mommy and daddy” time.

It’s the “affordable” vacation you took with your family, sleeping on back-breaking air-filled mattresses, wiping ash off hot dogs that fell into the fire pit and constantly fighting off ever-persistant bugs.

And, in hockey circles, it’s the time when players, fans and media endure the drudgery of rehearsals, and the working out of bugs, all the while itching for the real thing.

Despite having a “get out of jail/camp free” card in the form of no formal deal with the Ducks, Teemu Selanne signed a pro tryout contract Friday. The 38-year-old unrestricted free agent is poised to sign with the Anaheim as soon as GM Brian Burke frees up the requisite salary cap space by trading defenseman Mathieu Schneider.

Burke will move Schneider at some point; he says he had several offers from his peers earlier this summer and now it’s a question of finding the right fit. Burke had been hoping to dump Schneider’s $5.625 million salary cap hit for 2008-09 without having to assume a contract in return, hence the waiver move. With that no longer an option, Burke’s trading acumen will be put to the test.

He says may have to wait until a potential swapping partner runs into injury trouble and becomes more desperate for help. Of course, that’s something of a poker game.

Burke’s dilemma is trying to secure a decent bounty for Schneider without absorbing much salary in return. Either way, one of the game’s leading minds – and our No. 1-ranked GM last year – is under the microscope. The hockey world is intently watching to see how deftly he escapes his self-imposed shackles.

GRETZKY 4 COACH?
Now that The Great One has taken himself out of the running for the GM position with the Canadian Olympic team, rumblings have begun about him being coach in 2010. I’m not sure that’s what he’s bucking for, but I have mixed opinions on it regardless.

Related Links

My gut reaction is no, he hasn’t proven himself yet as a head coach at the NHL level. While he has done a decent job so far with the Coyotes, he’s still in development as a head coach and a stint as someone’s Olympic assistant – say, Mike Babcock or Randy Carlyle – could be highly beneficial.

On the other hand, he is The Great One, the best player in the history of our game, an icon who has been a winner all his life. That should count for something.

An added consideration is Vancouver could be the final time we see NHLers at the Games – especially if team owners have their way.

What would you do?

DOLLAR DAZE
For me, the most ominous quote from the Board of Governors meetings in Toronto this week was uttered by Edmonton Oilers president and CEO Patrick LaForge.

“I’m praying that the Canadian dollar stops where it is and stabilizes,” LaForge said, “because obviously it affects our business big time.”

Praying? Are the state of league finances so fragile they depend mightily on the rise and fall of the Canadian buck? Our supposition is yes, the swelling of NHL revenues the past few years has had much to do with the ballooning of the Loonie and, conversely, a pinprick in the dollar will seriously deflate the business.

And if a worst-case scenario plays out – a pending dramatic drop in the cap, players’ escrow money absorbed by the owners – what bearing will it have on the union’s prerogative to terminate the CBA next May?

The Canadian dollar has dropped about five cents from par with the U.S. dollar the past few months, closing at 95.2 cents Friday.

Jason Kay is the editor in chief of The Hockey News and a regular contributor to THN.com. His blog appears every weekend.

For more great profiles, news and views from the world of hockey, Subscribe to The Hockey News magazine.

COMMENTS (42)

Sort: Oldest | Newest | Love | Hate    Filter: All | Videos


daniel Posted
(2009-04-30 07:02:43)



right on the money craig. i don't follow the ducks that much, cause i'm a kings fan. i just loved the way that sounded man.
    0



Craig Posted
(2009-04-30 07:02:10)



for the last freaking time, the much over hyped Burke did not get Vancouver to the playoffs! Naslund was already here. Preheadcase Bertuzzi was already here. Ohlund was already here. A still effective, and enrgized McCabe was here. Burke took two of the best russian snipers ever (Bure and Mogilny) and turned them into Vadim Sharifjanov and Ed Jovanovski and Peter Zezel. I doubt anyone knows who two of the three are, and Jovo, while good will never be mistaken for Niedermayer or Lidstrom. Burke needed to find a center and a goalie. After repeated attempts (Sharifjanov, Denis Pederson, Zezel, an over the hill Dave Gagner, Darby Hendrickson Andrew Cassels, Trevor Letowski) he settled on Morrison. As for Goalies the best he came up with was Cloutier? and this was after playing musical goalies putting over a dozen through the crease in 6 years. Essensa, Potvin, Irbe, Burke, Snow, Legacy, Hedberg, Weekes, Auld, Brochu, (Tyler) Moss, Schwab, Skudra and eventually Cloutier. That's alot of mistakes for 6 years don't you think, with the solution being Dan Cloutier? His drafting was no better. Sure he got the Sedins, but no other Brian Burke pick has made an impact in the league, and none of the first rounders (top talent like Nathan Smith) have played for the club. He won nothing here and then left. Sure he got a cup in Anaheim, but I think he gets tomuch credit there. Yeah, he had the fortitude to bring in Neidermayer and Pronger; but Selanne came to him, and he almost said no. Perry, Getzlaf, MacDonald, Kunitz, Penner, Pahlson and Giguere were already in place. Look at what the "best" GM has done since then. Wasted salary cap space on Bertuzzi, and then bought the man out, stymied himself with the schnieder signing. Traded Macdonald for an over the hill Dough Weight. Waived Bryzgalov, getting nothing in return for a player that was one of the best goalies in the league last year. Lost Dustin Penner, and then had a temper tantrum about it. Sure seems effective eh? Maybe you want to point to his handling of the Selanne and Neidermayer retirements as an excuse. I would point out that the best GMs (Lamoreillo, and Holland) , the ones that don't get fired, and have won repeated cups, have never had this problem. Burke is a locust who will ravage a franchise and then flee for greener pastures, A LOUD MOUTHED OPPORTUNIST! and nothing more.
    0



Cory Posted
(2009-04-30 07:02:07)



Thanks Scott, I had been wondering about that. Burke is incredibly mediocre. Yes he got Vancouver to the playoffs but steadfastly refused to change his goalie, even though Cloutier was terrible. They managed to win only one playoff series in his time there and by the time he got let go the cupboards were bare so that Nonis walked in to a terrible situation. He's doing the exact same thing in Anaheim now. They don't have a lot of future. Once Selanne and Niedermayer retire for good that Ducks team is gonna struggle.
    0



Scott Posted
(2009-04-30 07:02:05)



Hey Cory, Burke resigned R. Neidermayer, he did not bring him in himself. I have to go with what seems to be the prevailing wisdom here, and that is that Burke really is not a good GM. Of course, he is not the only GM in cap trouble this year (Paul Holmgren is right up to it also), but Burke has consistently made mistakes and run his team poorly since his time in Vancouver. Proof of this can be found most specifically in two instances of last season regarding Scott Neidermayer and Teemu Selanne. Despite their talent, what kind of moron would allow his two best players to take half of the season off only to allow them to return at the cost of a younger player and serious salary cap issues. All in all, this is how Burke got into the trouble he's in now. Schneider is overpaid, but he wouldn't have had to do that if he had been firm with Neidermayer in the first place. And He would still have Andy MacDonald if he had done the same with Selanne and thus not had to sign Bertuzzi. Maybe I'm simplifying things, but most teams wouldn't allow for such behavior by their players, even their top players. Burke doesn't even rank in the top half of GMs in the league for me, let alone the top five (Holland, Poile, Gainey, Shero, Holmgren/Lamourello). As for who chooses the Canadian Olympic team, it doesn't take a genius to make those decisions, just don't do something stupid and Make Sidney Crosby or Mike Richards the captain. That should go to Iginla, Doan or Lecavalier. Also give Braydon Coburn a look on D, by then Coburn, Shea Weber, and Dion Phaneuf will probably be Canada's top 3.
    0



Brian Kemp Posted
(2009-04-30 07:02:01)



My apologies, Ian, for mistaking you for a Burke supporter. Also, after further research, it seems you are correct about which Canucks GM let Jovo go for nothing. I agree with you that he is so-so as a GM, however, I don't care for his style. Really, my problem isn't with Burke (although I stand by not wanting him anywhere near the Wings), but rather with the media for singing his praises, and putting him in the upper echelon of GMs. He's in the middle somewhere, not near the top. For every good move he's made, he's made at least as many bad moves.
    0



baijiansi Posted
(2009-04-30 07:01:59)



Burke is the most overrated person (player or staff) in hockey. The team that won the Cup wasn't really his (half Murray's to say the least) and now he's struggling with the cap. Plus he's a jerk. Go ahead Leafs, help yourself and hire him...
    0



baijiansi Posted
(2009-04-30 07:01:59)



And Burke never won anything in Vancouver. And since he's the priciest GM in hockey he's way overpaid. But hey, go ahead Leafs, don't give up on him...
    0



daniel Posted
(2009-04-30 07:01:50)



like i said cory, i am a kings fan. i don't keep track of them that much. but they always seem to flirt with the cap ceiling and put together a right nucleus. all i'm saying is that there owners and GM or GM's should i say, gave there fans something to watch the last 4-5 maybe 6 seasons. they seem like an organization that wants to win, not like the ownership of the kings the pathetic AEG company. granted, kings are an up and coming team. that's the point i was trying to make. another thing is yeah flirting with the cap ceiling isn't that good, but if you could balance that out for ever since the cap was brought in in 2004. that's pretty good managing. as for schneider, i hope he goes to the Kings with that big salary of his. as for Lombardi, give something O'Sullivan can't refuse for a long term contract. The kid will pay off sooner than later and will be worth every cent. give him i think a 4-5 year deal worth 30 mil. the kid is worth every cent. he should be making 5-6 mil a year and will prove it especially if he goes to a different team. SO SIGN HIM!!!
    0



Flyer guy Posted
(2009-04-30 07:01:43)



Is your point that they should have traded him rather than let him walk for nothing? That makes more sense.
    0



Flyer guy 16 Posted
(2009-04-30 07:01:42)



Ben, why are you calling me a dummy and then agreeing with what I was saying? He was paid 6 because he was worth it at the time (according to who?),he was over rated, a liability on defense,and should have been traded.I'm a dummy but you agree with me? I don't get your point.What am I missing?
    0



1 2 3 4 5

ADD YOUR COMMENT

Register or Login to submit a comment
Player/Injury News - Up to the Minute NHL Updates This Week - Subscribe Now

Who wins the Smyth-Quincey/Preissing trade?




THN Newsletter - Sign Up Now

"I'm not here to replace him."

- Martin Havlat, who signed with Minnesota a few hours after former Wild star Marian Gaborik inked a UFA deal with the Rangers.

Our Partners