• Print

THN.com Blog: 10 scrappers worth talking about

Daniel Carcillo exchanges blows with Colin Fraser during a fight last season. (Photo by Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images)

Zoom Image

Daniel Carcillo exchanges blows with Colin Fraser during a fight last season. (Photo by Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images)

Coming off a week that put me in a fighting mood, I figured it was a good time to have some fun and look at 10 of the NHL’s top pugilists.

(That and it’ll really stick in the craw of staunch pacifists Adam Proteau and Ken Campbell).

Milan Lucic, Boston (13 fights in ’07-08)
He probably can’t throw with the heavyweights, but watching the young buck prior to concussion problems last season was still a true treat…oh, and he has the potential to develop into a top power forward, too.

Georges Laraque, Montreal (13 fights in ’07-08)
With Laraque, it’s more about quality than quantity. And that’s a product of no one wanting to step up to the 240-pound behemoth. The Habs took a big step forward in the arms race this off-season.

Jared Boll, Columbus (27 fights in ’07-08)
Led the league in tilts last season. As soon as he adds a few pounds to his 6-foot-2, 190-pound frame he’ll be one of the game’s elite, if he isn’t already.

George Parros, Anaheim (23 fights in ’07-08)
The man with the moustache was part of several memorable scraps last season; his toe-to-toe with David Koci jumps to mind (has Koci ever been in a boring fight?).

Riley Cote, Philadelphia (24 fights in ’07-08)
I couldn’t very well leave the league’s second-most prolific fighter off the list, could I? This guy can’t do anything but chuck, but Philly liked him enough to give him a three-year deal in July.

Zdeno Chara, Boston (four fights in ’07-08)
He’s too valuable to be tossing haymakers on a regular basis, so when the extra-large Slovak decides it’s time, it’s a real bonus.

Related Links

Sean Avery, Dallas (six fights in ’07-08)
He doesn’t drop the gloves often, but when he does get into it his opponent really wants to hurt the new Stars agitator, which makes for added entertainment value.

David Clarkson, New Jersey (21 fights in ’07-08)
Another NHLer who fits into the more-than-just-a-fighter category, the sophomore right winger found the net nine times in between knuckle-chuckings.

Daniel Carcillo, Phoenix (19 fights in ’07-08)
One of only two fighters amongst the 10 standing under six feet tall (Avery), he’s also the list’s second-most complete forward (again, Avery). It’s not beyond the realm of possibility he’ll develop into a 30-goal, 300-PIM beast.

Zack Stortini, Edmonton (23 fights in ’07-08)
Tied with Parros for third-most tilts in the NHL – in three less games – Stortini, 22, is another up-and-coming scrapper. If the Oil’s plethora of young offensive talent doesn’t excite you, maybe Stortini will do the trick.

* all fighting statistics courtesy of HockeyFights.com

Edward Fraser is the editor of thehockeynews.com. His blog normally appears Fridays.

For more great profiles, news and views from the world of hockey, Subscribe to The Hockey News magazine.

COMMENTS (76)

Sort: Oldest | Newest    Filter: All | Videos


James Svantner Posted
(2009-04-30 07:37:41)



Clark Gilles.....show me ONE fight he lost and I'll say I was wrong! Until then, thank you and have a good night! Probert a close second!
    0



VMAN Posted
(2009-04-30 07:32:24)



Colton Orr Enough SAID!!!
    0



scrum Posted
(2009-04-30 07:01:08)



sugar is coming N Y I
    0



Jake Posted
(2009-04-30 06:59:22)



No Andrew Peters?
    0



Kevin Posted
(2009-04-30 06:59:10)



BOB PROBERT!!!
    0



Scott Posted
(2009-04-30 06:58:48)



No Darcy Hordichuk, no Jody Shelley? no Scott Parker? Not a very good list.
    0



Hockey fan Posted
(2009-04-30 06:58:47)



How's Raitis not on that list. He's dominated 1/2 of these guys and the other 1/2 are afraid to fight the Latvian freight train.
    0



Chris K Posted
(2009-04-30 06:58:42)



Was the list produced by a bad computer that dates back to the Reagan era??? Avery and a few others on the list would spend an eternity at the nearest hospital if they were insane enough to trade blows with Brashear (even if he'll be a senior citizen quite soon) or the Bogeyman among others. Here is a list of the top offensive defensemen: 1. Wade Belak 2. Mike Komisarek 3. Jeff Fingers 4. Francis Bouillon 5. Colton Orr
    0



kid247 Posted
(2009-04-30 06:58:33)



Stortini??? Stortini!!!??? Are we talking best fighters here or best huggers? Every time this dork fights, I cringe - - - Colton Orr, Wade Belak and even Chris Neil have way more clout than this freakshow. Sorry THN - this was a big error on your part to include him.
    0



Eric Posted
(2009-04-30 06:58:28)



Only someone who has never watch Cote fight can put him on this list, especially if Orr isn't on it. Everytime those two fight Orr beats him like Kocur used to beat people.
    0



1 2 3 ...6 7 8

ADD YOUR COMMENT

Register or Login to submit a comment
Player/Injury News - Up to the Minute NHL Updates This Week - Subscribe Now

Who should start in goal for Russia at the Olympics?






THN Newsletter - Sign Up Now

“I was coming in to take the boards away and had some good jump. He bobbled the puck at the last second and I don’t think he saw me coming at all. It was a shoulder right in his chest. He’s eight feet tall, so it’s not like you could hit him in the head.”

- Ottawa's Chris Neil about a hit he threw on Tampa's Victor Hedman Thursday night, causing Hedman to leave the game.

Our Partners